Mar 14, 2004 Now that there is official errata and this is not included, but yet they are deffnitely aware of the problem, the only conclusions I can draw are that the rules committee has decided that Andy is wrong and that PrC penalties are correct or that the whole 3.5 process is riddled with more problems than 3.0 which at least got all its errata out in.
@JeremyECrawford Are Potions of Healing Magic or Mundane items in terms of 5e crafting?
— tony (@perception101) December 6, 2016
A potion of healing is magical. See the first sentence of its description (PH, 153). #DnDhttps://t.co/2615ihJoDK
— Jeremy Crawford (@JeremyECrawford) December 6, 2016
@Mazoshi1987But that means only casters can create them even though phb states you can make them with a herbalist kit? I'm curious, where do you interpret the PH saying that an herbalism kit gives you the ability to make a potion of healing?
— Jeremy Crawford (@JeremyECrawford) December 6, 2016
@perception101@Mazoshi1987but I guess you’re going to say, required, but not sufficient – which clears up a LOT of confusion 🙂 Bingo. The kit is required but not sufficient.
— Jeremy Crawford (@JeremyECrawford) December 6, 2016
@perception101@Mazoshi1987 Cool, thanks. Funny what you can read into a single sentence (along with half of reddit it seems). There are many phantom rules on the loose online.
— Jeremy Crawford (@JeremyECrawford) December 6, 2016
@perception101@Mazoshi1987aye, but the flipside is we can now clear stuff up in real time! Appreciate you taking the time for this. My pleasure!
— Jeremy Crawford (@JeremyECrawford) December 6, 2016
![Dmg Dmg](/uploads/1/2/5/8/125825736/856352569.jpg)
@JeremyECrawford WAit, shit, I just got around to checking the DMG. Kinda sad that Healing Potions are always made at a loss.
— Torbjørn Brekke (@Tobbun) December 8, 2016
As of the DMG errata, potions and other consumable magic items cost half as much to make: https://t.co/kuNYh24QEY#DnDhttps://t.co/8BE2q1RBfJ
— Jeremy Crawford (@JeremyECrawford) December 8, 2016